Skip to main content

24 Unique Thanksgiving Pies

24 Unique Thanksgiving Pies
Body First

Thanksgiving is all about pie! Usually you can find a dessert table full of pumpkin, pecan, and apple pies, but with so many diverse pies out there, why limit yourself to just three? Here are 24 delicious and unique options that will be perfect for Thanksgiving.

 

1. Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie

24 Unique Thanksgiving Pies

This chocolate chip cookie pie from The Girl Who Ate Everything is like two great desserts in one!

 

2. Pomegranate Yogurt Pie

24 Unique Thanksgiving Pies

If you want a healthier pie option, this pie from Ilona's Passion might be the way to go. It is tasty version without all the calories you find in most pies.

 

3. Raspberry Coconut Sour Cream Pie

24 Unique Thanksgiving Pies

This creamy and sweet pie from Crunchy Creamy Sweet might seem like a summer classic, but it will fit in perfectly with your Thanksgiving feast.

 

4. Peanut Butter Fudge Pie with Caramel

24 Unique Thanksgiving Pies

Peanut butter and chocolate is a crowd pleasing combination. This pie from Taste and Tell brings them together beautifully.

 

5. Cream Puff Pie

24 Unique Thanksgiving Pies

This pie from Cooking Classy uses puff pastry as a pie crust combined with a creamy and fluffy filling for a unique pie experience.

 

6. Chocolate Pear Pie

24 Unique Thanksgiving Pies

Pears are often underutilized fall fruits perfect for Thanksgiving. This pie from Crunchy Creamy Sweet uses pears and chocolate together in perfect harmony.

 

7. Toffee Marshmallow Pie

24 Unique Thanksgiving Pies

This pie from Taste and Tell is fluffy, light, and delicious. Plus, it's super easy to make for a busy chef.

 

8. Hazelnut Chocolate Chess Pie

24 Unique Thanksgiving Pies

This pie from Adventures in Cooking is a great replacement for pecan pie if you want to change things up without vearing too far from the classics.

 

9. Cranberry Fluff Pie

24 Unique Thanksgiving Pies

Cranberries are a Thanksgiving classic. Make them into a light and fluffy pie with this recipe from Lauren's Latest.

 

10. Oatmeal Walnut Butterscotch Pie

24 Unique Thanksgiving Pies

Butterscotch is a fun flavor perfect for the Thanksgiving table. This pie from Sugar Hero mixes it with oatmeal and walnuts.

 

11. S'mores Pudding Pie

24 Unique Thanksgiving Pies

S'mores is the perfect flavor for autumn when it starts to get cold out. Bring that campfire feeling to your Thanksgiving table with this pie from What's Gaby Cooking.

 

12. Banana Cream Pie

24 Unique Thanksgiving Pies

Banana cream pie is a classic pie, but it's not one you usually find at Thanksgiving. This one from The Girl Who Ate Everything will fit right in to your meal.

 

13. Cranberry Sage Pie

24 Unique Thanksgiving Pies

Cranberry and sage are a delicious fall combination. This pie from Hint of Vanilla combines them to make the perfect Thanksgiving pie.

 

14. Coconut Cream Pie

24 Unique Thanksgiving Pies

This coconut cream pie from The Pinning Mama is sweet and creamy. It's sure to be a crowd pleaser.

 

15. Salted Caramel Pie

24 Unique Thanksgiving Pies

Salted caramel is a popular flavor that all your Thaksgiving guest will love. Make this pie from Favorite Family Recipes to sweeten your dessert.

 

16. Winter Squash Pie

24 Unique Thanksgiving Pies

This winter squash pie from Heartbeet Kitchen is a hearty pie that is both savory and sweet.

 

17. Chocolate Mousse Cheesecake Pie

24 Unique Thanksgiving Pies

If you are a cheesecake and chocolate lover, this pie from Mel's Kitchen Cafe will be perfect for your Thanksgiving table.

 

18. Cinnamon Buttermilk Pie

24 Unique Thanksgiving Pies

Cinnamon is a supporting player in many pies, but this pie from The Little Epicurean makes it the star of the show.

 

19. Donut Pie

24 Unique Thanksgiving Pies

If you want to have a non-traditional and fun Thanksgiving dinner, this donut pie from Aww Sam will be completely unique and original.

 

20. Lemon Brulee Pie

24 Unique Thanksgiving Pies

Anyone can make a lemon meringue pie. Change it up with this lemon brulee pie from Self Proclaimed Foodie.

 

21. Sweet Potato Coconut Pie with Marshmallow Meringue

24 Unique Thanksgiving Pies

Sweet potato casserole is traditionally served at Thanksgiving with marshmallow topping. Make it a part of the dessert instead with this pie from Taste and Tell.

 

22. Brownie Pie

24 Unique Thanksgiving Pies

This brownie pie from Cooking Classy is a great way to serve two beloved desserts at the same time.

 

23. Cranberry Pear Pie

24 Unique Thanksgiving Pies

This pie from Tastes of Lizzy T is two great autumn fruits in one delicious package.

 

24. Salty Honey Pie

24 Unique Thanksgiving Pies

This pie from Annie's Eats is the best of salty and sweet, a delicious combination that everyone will love.

24 Unique Thanksgiving Pies
Holiday Observance